The study examined the relative effectiveness of monetary (money supply, interest rate, exchange rate, inflation rate) and fiscal policy (government capital expenditure, recurrent expenditure, tax revenue and external debt) on unemployment in Nigeria from 1986 to 2023. The study employed the Auto Regressive Distributive Lag (ARDL) and Error Correction Models (ECM) as the primary estimation technique to capture the short and long run effects. Monetary policy model and fiscal policy model were identified and estimated separately. In the monetary model the study found that interest rate, exchange rate, and inflation affect unemployment only after 2- 3 years while money supply has no significant short-run effect and only becomes effective in the long run. The fiscal policy model show that capital expenditure significantly reduces unemployment in both the short and long run while recurrent expenditure and debt strongly increase unemployment. Importantly, government tax revenue consistently shows a negative but statistically insignificant effect on unemployment in both the short and long run with. The study therefore, concluded that fiscal policy is relatively more effective than monetary policy in reducing unemployment in Nigeria. Based on this finding, the study recommended that for Nigeria to meaningfully reduce unemployment, government should focus on implementing stronger and productive fiscal policies since they are more impactful, while monetary policy should play a supportive rather than primary role in labour market stabilisation.
Keywords: Monetary Policy, Fiscal Policy, Unemployment, Relative Effectiveness, ARDL, ECM