Electoral credibility remains a persistent concern in Nigeria’s democratic development, particularly where contested presidential election outcomes are subjected to prolonged judicial scrutiny. Although post-election judicial intervention provides a constitutional mechanism for resolving electoral disputes, the extent to which such intervention enhances electoral credibility remains contested. This study examined the impact of post-election judicial intervention on the credibility of presidential elections in Nigeria between 2011 and 2023. Specifically, it assessed the adequacy and effectiveness of the legal and institutional framework governing post-election adjudication; determined the extent to which judicial independence and impartiality influenced the adjudication of presidential election disputes; assessed the influence of transparency, consistency and procedural fairness on confidence in presidential election outcomes; and determined the effect of post-election judicial intervention on the credibility and acceptance of presidential election outcomes. The study was anchored on Democratic Legitimacy Theory and adopted a mixed-method research design. Quantitative data were obtained through structured questionnaires administered to relevant electoral stakeholders, while qualitative evidence was generated through key-informant interviews and documentary analysis of constitutional provisions, Electoral Acts, election petitions and judicial decisions relating to the 2011, 2015, 2019 and 2023 presidential elections. Quantitative data were analysed using frequencies, percentages, means and inferential statistics, while qualitative data were analysed thematically and triangulated with documentary evidence. The findings indicate that Nigeria possesses an established legal and institutional framework for electoral adjudication, but procedural complexity and evidentiary requirements constrain its effectiveness. Judicial independence and impartiality were found to be important determinants of confidence in electoral adjudication, while perceptions of political influence weakened public trust. Transparency, consistency and procedural fairness also influenced stakeholders’ confidence in judicial decisions. Overall, post-election judicial intervention contributes positively to electoral credibility when judicial processes are perceived as independent, transparent, consistent and fair, but its legitimacy is weakened where technical requirements, perceived political influence and inconsistent interpretations undermine confidence. The study recommends strengthening the independence and institutional capacity of electoral adjudication, clarifying procedural and evidentiary rules, improving transparency in judicial processes, and strengthening the preservation and accessibility of electoral evidence. The study concludes that the democratic value of judicial intervention lies not merely in resolving election petitions, but in producing decisions capable of commanding legal legitimacy, public confidence and acceptance of electoral outcomes.