This study examines the role of ethnicity and religion in shaping national integration within Nigeria’s federal structure, with particular attention to the effectiveness of institutional mechanisms designed to manage diversity. Anchored in Social Identity Theory, the study conceptualises identity as a socially constructed and politically activated category through which individuals derive belonging, loyalty, and group alignment. The research adopts a mixed methods design, integrating quantitative survey data (n = 382) with qualitative interviews across six strategically selected states: Lagos State, Kwara State, Enugu State, Adamawa State, Rivers State, and Kaduna State. The study population is drawn from an estimated 39 million residents, with a refined target population of approximately 4.16 million individuals actively engaged in civic and religious organisations, based on data from the National Population Commission, National Bureau of Statistics, World Bank, and United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. The findings reveal that ethnicity and religion remain deeply embedded in Nigeria’s political and social systems, functioning not merely as identity markers but as instruments of mobilisation and access. Quantitative results show consistently high agreement levels exceeding 70 percent across indicators measuring the impact of identity on political cooperation, trust, and national cohesion. Notably, 85.4 percent of respondents identified elite manipulation of ethnic and religious identities as a central driver of division. Qualitative evidence further demonstrates that identity influences everyday social relations, shapes perceptions of state legitimacy, and conditions access to opportunities across regions. The study also identifies a significant gap between the awareness and effectiveness of national integration mechanisms, including the National Youth Service Corps and the Federal Character Principle. The study concludes that national integration in Nigeria is constrained not by diversity itself, but by the institutional and political context within which identities are mobilised. It recommends a shift from symbolic inclusion to structural reforms that promote equitable access, strengthen institutional credibility, and foster a shared civic identity. This research contributes to the literature by providing a multi-level analysis of integration that bridges identity theory, governance practice, and empirical evidence within the Nigerian context.