The Nigerian quest for sustainable development has been recurrently marred by loopholes, blockades, and setbacks that have hindered linear progress along the trajectory of development. This study examines the effect of insecurity on sustainable development in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic, with particular emphasis on state-driven peace initiatives between 2010 and 2023. The study is motivated by the persistent rise in violent conflicts, including farmer–herder clashes, banditry, and inter-communal disputes, which have increasingly undermined development efforts across the country. Adopting a mixed-methods approach, the study combines quantitative data derived from structured questionnaires analysed using the Relative Importance Index (RII) with qualitative insights obtained from secondary sources and Key Informant Interviews. The analysis focuses on selected conflict-prone states, including Kaduna State, Kwara State, and Oyo State, while also drawing comparative insights from the Middle Belt region. The findings reveal that insecurity constitutes a major structural constraint to sustainable development, significantly disrupting economic activities, agricultural productivity, and social cohesion. Results from the RII indicate strong agreement among respondents that loss of lives, displacement, and economic instability represent the most critical consequences of insecurity. The study further finds that although state-driven peace initiatives, such as dialogue platforms and community-based interventions, demonstrate moderate effectiveness, their overall impact remains limited by political interference, weak institutional capacity, and low public trust. A comparative analysis highlights that insecurity in Nigeria is highly context-specific, with northern states experiencing higher intensity and more complex conflict patterns than the relatively moderate and emerging threats observed in southern regions. The study concludes that insecurity in Nigeria reflects broader governance deficits rather than mere security failures. It therefore recommends context-sensitive, community-driven, and institutionally supported peacebuilding strategies as essential pathways towards achieving sustainable development.