The conflict between Share and Tsaragi has recurred intermittently due to several factors, including the improper use of information under the guise of freedom of expression. Information has often been used to mobilise community members against rival groups and attract third-party support, thereby escalating inter-communal violence. This study investigated the effect of information quality on the Share–Tsaragi inter-communal conflict in Kwara State, Nigeria. Specifically, the study examined the effects of information quality on conflict escalation and explored challenges confronting the use of information in conflict de-escalation. The study adopted a descriptive research design using quantitative and qualitative methods. Through purposive sampling, 140 respondents, including security operatives and residents knowledgeable about information dissemination before, during, and after the conflict, were selected from both communities. Of the 140 copies of the questionnaire administered, 139 were retrieved and analysed using descriptive statistics. In addition, nine oral interview sessions involving six Key Informant Interviews (KII) and eight In-Depth Interviews (IDI) were conducted among community members and security operatives, while qualitative data were analysed using content analysis. Findings revealed that inadequate information quality contributed to fragile peace, breakdown of peace agreements, mobilisation of armed combatants, and the spread of conflict to neighbouring communities. Findings further showed challenges identified as lack of deterrents against harmful information dissemination, low inter-community trust, and inadequate media peace education. The study concluded that wrongful information dissemination has sustained and escalated the Share–Tsaragi conflict and recommended public sensitisation and strengthened of peace-building initiatives.