Moisture-induced deterioration is a major cause of premature pavement failure in tropical regions where expansive clay soils are widely used as subgrade materials. Conventional evaluation methods assess engineering properties such as soaked California Bearing Ratio (CBR), compaction characteristics, moisture demand, and hydraulic conductivity independently, limiting holistic assessment of subgrade performance. This study developed a dimensionless HydroMechanical Stability Index (HMSI) for evaluating the hydro-mechanical stability of tropical black clay subgrades. Representative soil samples were collected from twenty trial pits across four locations in North-Central Nigeria, namely Gwagwalada, Gidigidi, Sunti, and Zungeru. Laboratory investigations included determination of index properties, compaction characteristics, hydraulic conductivity, and soaked CBR in accordance with relevant ASTM and British Standard procedures. The investigated soils were classified as CH, CL, and CL–CH under the Unified Soil Classification System (USCS) and as A-7-5 and A-7-6 according to AASHTO, confirming their generally poor suitability as untreated pavement subgrades. The proposed HMSI integrates soaked CBR, normalized maximum dry density, optimum moisture content, and normalized hydraulic conductivity into a single dimensionless engineering parameter. Computed HMSI values ranged from 0.0397 to 0.2263, enabling the investigated deposits to be ranked according to their relative hydro-mechanical stability. Sensitivity analysis demonstrated that the index responds consistently to variations in its constituent engineering parameters, with soaked CBR and maximum dry density exerting positive influences, whereas optimum moisture content and hydraulic conductivity reduced the computed stability. The proposed preliminary classification framework identified Gwagwalada, Gidigidi, Zungeru, and Sunti deposits as exhibiting Very Poor, Poor, Moderate, and Good hydro-mechanical stability, respectively. Although broader validation is required, HMSI provides a practical screening tool for subgrade ranking, stabilization prioritization, and preliminary pavement assessment using routinely determined laboratory parameters, thereby supporting climate-resilient pavement engineering in tropical environments.
Keywords: Hydro-Mechanical Stability Index (HMSI); Tropical Black Clay; Expansive Soil; Pavement Subgrade; Moisture-Induced Instability.